Today's Market Observation 04.23.2009 Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Shedlock Archive
Twilight Zone Treasuries
BY MIKE SHEDLOCK | april 23, 2009
In accordance with its "print to buy" program, today the Fed bought another $7 billion of Treasuries.
U.S. Fed buys $7 bln of Treasuries on Thursday
Thu Apr 23, 2009 11:09am EDT
The Federal Reserve bought $7 billion of Treasuries maturing between May 2012 and August 2013 on Thursday, the New York Fed said on its Website.
Dealers submitted $15.99 billion for consideration in the purchase. The Fed made its heaviest purchases in Treasuries maturing in May 2013 and June 2012, respectively.
The Fed said at its last meeting it intends to buy $300 billion in Treasury securities over six months in a bid to lower long-term borrowing costs and revive economic growth.
Inquiring minds are looking at a chart to see what the market thinks of this manipulation.
$TYX - 30 Year Long Bond Yield
click on chart for sharper image
$TNX - 10 Year Treasury Note Yield
click on chart for sharper image
The Fed also purchased $7 billion on Tuesday. Professor Fil Zucchi on Minyanville had this succinct comment:
"Today the Federal Reserve printed $7 billion dollars and used it to buy an equivalent amount of 7 and 10 year Treasury bonds. As I publicly asked before, if Mr. Fed can't rig the price of an asset by buying it with printed money, why should anyone else buy it?"
Those wishing to keep an eye on these price rigging attempts can follow the Federal Reserve Bank Permanent OMOs: Treasury link.
Bernanke's Hubris
It is ridiculous for the Fed to think it can control the vast $trillion treasury market with pea shooting efforts at $7 billion a pea. However, as the charts above show, the Fed announcement hugely distorted the market in smaller timeframes.
As Prof. Zucchi says "If Mr. Fed can't rig the price of an asset by buying it with printed money, why else should anyone else buy it?"
Other than the initial pop, the Fed's silly attempt to game the system may have caused so much mistrust that it is putting upward pressure on yields.
What we do know for sure is that Bernanke's efforts to prevent deflation have failed spectacularly as documented in Bernanke's Deflation Preventing Scorecard.
That 10 year treasury wedge is likely to break sharp in one direction or the other. The competing arguments are substantial:
Case For and Against Treasuries
- The idea of a sustainable economic recovery starting in the second half is a farce. A collapsing recovery effort will renew a flight to safety in treasuries.
- The Fed is printing massive amounts of dollars to bailout the banks in an effort that is also doomed to fail. The Fed's printing is putting upward pressure on yields.
- Seasonality on treasuries is negative from January through May. Seasonality turns positive in June. How much more selloff is left?
- The Fed's blatant attempt to force yields lower is arguably counterproductive.
Regardless of what happens, this seems to be a poor place to initiate shorts. The time to short treasuries was December or the subsequent retest of the yield low in January. There is little reason to enter a trade in the Twilight Zone with all these competing factors.
Mike 'Mish' Shedlock
Copyright © 2009 All rights reserved.
contact information
Michael Shedlock
Observation Archive
