The Shape & Future of Indian Gold Demand – Part 2/2

  • Print

The Misleading Rupee

The Indian gold investor still has one weakness –his understanding of the Rupee itself in pricing gold. As we are all guilty of, the Indian investor measures the price of gold in the Rupee and rarely measures the price of the Rupee in terms of gold. Consequently as the Rupee weakens, he sees the price of gold rising, when it is not. That’s the case in today’s market. In the past the Rupee has been as strong as Rs.30 :$1. Last year it was Rs.42 whereas today it’s at Rs.55.81. To illustrate; let’s take a gold price of $1,500. At Rs.30: $1 it is Rs.45,000 per ounce. At Rs.42: $1 it is Rs.63,000. At Rs.55.81: $1 it is Rs.83,715.

This is fooling the present Indian market into believing the gold price is ‘spiking’, whereas in the dollar it’s 16.5% off its high! Until Indians understand the function of the Rupee in pricing, they’ll be fooled by it. At the moment they are standing back from the gold market waiting for prices to fall and even selling gold in the hope to buy back cheaper. We doubt whether the Rupee will strengthen for a long time to come.

Disposable Income a Restraint

Just as in other parts of the world, the one limiting factor on gold buying is disposable income. Because he’s buying as saving, he’ll buy anyway. As the price rises, the volume of gold, which his disposable income will buy, gets smaller. Therefore, Indian demand for gold will be driven –as was the last decade— by savings and real income levels and not by price. Remember he was buying when gold was $35 an ounce, $100 an ounce $300 an ounce and now when gold is $1,600 an ounce he is still buying. Furthermore, history has confirmed by these rising prices that he was right. Some see it as a blessing from Ganesha, who we have heard, does not rely on Technical Analysis.

India's demand for the precious metal is estimated to fall by 4% in volume and rise 4% in value in 2012, according to Morgan Stanley. Respondents from several households said they expect gold prices to rise by 8% in 2012; however, an additional 8% to 10% rise would lead to a proportionate decline in volumes.

Indian households are increasing their demand for gold bars and coins. Morgan Stanley notes rising income is behind the growing share of gold bar holdings.

Buying gold as a backup for bad times accounted for 16% of those surveyed, while gifting on events was another 15%. When speaking about the reasons why they bought gold jewelry in the past 12 months, respondents said auspicious events like marriages and festival accounted for 35%, while investment demand accounted for 20%. Around 8% of those surveyed said they bought gold as an impulse buy or bought gold for no specific reason. Another 6% of those surveyed said they bought gold because they were fond of the precious metal.

From Rural to Urban, from seasonality to Less Seasonality

The rural agricultural sector, which accounts for 70% of the population, has been in the past the source of 2/3 of gold demand –this brought a sense of seasonality to the gold markets

Indian gold buying starts its year in mid-to-late August and carries on through until May of the next year. At the beginning of June, farmers must ensure crops are in the ground and ready for the annual monsoons, or tropical rains. So far, this year bodes well for a good monsoon. Harvesting takes place through August, which is when the farmers get their annual paychecks.

India is now experiencing the rapid growth of the Middle class and urbanization. This movement has quickened its pace in the last ten years to the extent that the U.N. believes that 41% of India’s total population will be living in towns and cities by 2030—up from the current level of 30%. More importantly, a good proportion of these will join the middle classes. 

Mckinsey reports, in 2010 there were 40 million consuming households in India with an annual income of more than U.S.$7,000. This figure is set to more than double to 94 million by 2020. The impact will be significant for gold, losing its seasonality and becoming a feature all year round.

The peak period for gold demand will continue to be from end-August through to end May, as the rural sector joins the new middle classes in buying gold and boosting demand to record highs, but will not fall away as it did in the past because of the famer’s timetable. Morgan Stanly expects volume demand to drop 13% for urban India and rise 4% for rural India this year.

With regards to the drivers of gold purchases, Morgan Stanly adds that so-called ‘life events' were responsible for around 45% of gold purchases by urban households in 2010, while discretionary consumption was around 25% and investment as a driver accounted for another 30%. In 2011, life events as a driver for purchase came down to 35%, and investment rocketed to around 40%. Discretionary consumption was the other 25%.

Morgan Stanly notes that Indian households are increasingly channeling their investment demand through bars or coins. The report projects a 2% to 3% point increase in share of bars and coins this year. The World Gold Council has said bars and coins represented 39% of total investment in 2011, a record high.

There are huge volumes of gold and silver bought over the last few decades there, so why doesn’t it leave the homes in which it is kept and travel to the market? Why don’t merchants then take it in at the prices they offer, parcel it up and ship it to the international markets to get the apparent profit? This is not the way Indian think. Only a small amount of gold or silver is exported from India, usually in the form of jewelry and sold to Indian expatriates overseas, particularly into the Middle East.

However, should the need arise for them to sell their gold and silver, they approach their dealer. When he buys, he has to report the transaction “officially” and pay purchase tax, which is enormous relative to his profits. He also would have to expose his complete business to the authorities, whose reputation for administering businesses is appallingly corrupt. Should he then want to export this purchased metal, he needs to reflect the metal in his accounts and confirm purchase tax has been paid. With a similar aversion to tax as one has to the plague, dealers buy such scrap for cash and hoard it in their own private, invisible stores.

Member’s only: Will they buy if gold prices rise?

Get the rest of the article. Subscribe @ Gold Forecaster / Silver Forecaster

Legal Notice / Disclaimer

This document is not and should not be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase or subscribe for any investment. Gold Forecaster - Global Watch / Julian D. W. Phillips / Peter Spina, have based this document on information obtained from sources it believes to be reliable but which it has not independently verified; Gold Forecaster - Global Watch / Julian D. W. Phillips / Peter Spina make no guarantee, representation or warranty and accepts no responsibility or liability as to its accuracy or completeness. Expressions of opinion are those of Gold Forecaster - Global Watch / Julian D. W. Phillips / Peter Spina only and are subject to change without notice. Gold Forecaster - Global Watch / Julian D. W. Phillips / Peter Spina assume no warranty, liability or guarantee for the current relevance, correctness or completeness of any information provided within this Report and will not be held liable for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or statement contained herein or any omission. Furthermore, we assume no liability for any direct or indirect loss or damage or, in particular, for lost profit, which you may incur as a result of the use and existence of the information, provided within this Report.

CLICK HERE to subscribe to the free weekly Best of Financial Sense Newsletter .

About Julian Phillips

Quantcast