|

NOLTE NOTES
20th
Anniversary for the 87' Crash
by Paul J.
Nolte, CFA
October 15, 2007
Friday
will mark the 20th anniversary of the crash of ’87
(Saturday will mark the 10th anniversary of the crash of
’97 – see an issue here?). We are not calling for an anniversary
crash, but the media is (and will be throughout the week) playing up the
day and noting some of the similarities to that bleak Monday not so long
ago. To be sure, there are major differences, key among them is
inflation running half of that in ’87 and interest rates are not
soaring to 10% as they were then. The main linkage between the two
periods is the dollar, falling during both periods and well below
historical ranges today. Economically speaking, the reports of the past
week indicated that the economy continues to grow at a modest pace
without high “core” inflation. However, when food and energy get
added back, year to year producer price growth is uncomfortably above
4%. The price of oil has not dropped as it has in the past once the main
driving season is done, and although the growing season was good,
agricultural prices continue to rise. Thankfully the foreign economies
continue to grow – so keep an eye on the economies of Europe and
China, for if they slow down, we could be in for a big surprise.
It
is said that bottoms in the markets are events and tops are processes.
If so, then the bottom following the 500-point decline in August would
be the event, and today’s struggle to push higher may be the process
that puts in “the” market top for the year. Volume figures for the
week have not been spectacular and once again rose as the markets fell,
indicating many more willing sellers than buyers. Many of our other
indicators, from a simple advance decline line (showing the net number
of advancing stocks) to more momentum based indicators are all showing
signs of diverging with the records reached by the Dow and SP500. By not
“confirming” the highs in the market, these indicators are showing
that all is not well below the surface of the markets – more stocks
are not participating in the advance, volume figures remain weak and
valuation/sentiment reading still point to high expectations by
investors. Disasters can ensue from these kinds of readings, but more
likely is that returns on stocks going forward are likely to be poor. As
we get into the meat of the earnings season, it will be very interesting
to see what and how companies couch their outlooks on both the economy
and business prospects.
While
our bond model continues at a positive reading, we are beginning to see
“excessive” excitement in the metals markets that may point to a
near-term top in gold (that in turn, would support interest rates). We
look at the ratio between gold stock prices and the price of the metal.
Historically gold stocks have traded within a range of roughly 1.4 to
1.8 times the price of bullion. From 1994 to well into 1997, gold stocks
traded nearly 2x the price of bullion, gold stocks subsequently fell by
60%. During the tech bubble, gold stocks were selling for less than the
price of bullion and have since tripled in price, recovering all that
was lost from 1996 to 2000. Today, the ratio is at its highest level
since 1996. A few things can happen here, either bullion prices rise
(and stocks remain steady) or bullion prices are stable while stock
prices decline. Bulls are betting both bullion and stock prices rise.

© 2007 Paul J. Nolte, CFA
Editorial
Archive
The
opinions expressed in the Investment Newsletter are those of the author
and are based upon information that is believed to be accurate and
reliable, but are opinions and do not constitute a guarantee of present
or future financial market conditions.
CONTACT
INFORMATION Paul J. Nolte, CFA
Director Investments
Hinsdale Associates
630-325-7100
Email
|