|
The Daily Reckoning PRESENTS
The derivatives market has reached a
face value of $480 trillion...30 times the size of the U.S.
economy...and 12 times the size of the entire world economy. Trading in
derivatives has become not merely a huge boom or even a large bubble -
but the mother of a whole tribe of bubbles...dripping little big bubbles
throughout the entire financial sector. Bill Bonner explores…
On
November 27th, a story appeared in the Financial Times telling
readers that rich investors were having to resort to ‘underhanded’
means and special favors in order to get into the best hedge funds.
Somewhere
in the dark mush of our own brain came a flicker of light...and the
ringing of a bell. We recalled how hard it was to get in on the Initial
Public Offers of the late ‘90s. All a fellow had to do was to put
together a plausible dot.com story and take it to the financial wizards
of Wall Street or the City. A few months later, actual shares of this
hypothetical business would hit the streets. And since managers found it
convenient for the shares to rise quickly following their release, they
were normally priced at a level where they were bound to go up, even
though they were already selling for far more than they were worth. This
meant that getting in on the early stages of the IPO was almost
guaranteed money-in-the-bank. And it is why Barbara Streisand, to cite a
famous example, would send tickets to her shows to IPO managers, hoping
for more than a round of applause.
Of
course, the dot.coms blew up in January 2000...and investment bankers
stopped getting the free tickets. Now, they’re going to hedge fund
managers.
But
the average fund has not been doing well; so far in 2006 you could have
done better by accident than by hedge fund. The typical fund is up only
about 7%. The FTSE has risen 9% and the Dow is up 15%. This seems only
to have made investors desperate to get into the tiny group of funds
that are doing well.
Well-established
and top performing funds are often ‘closed.’ They already have
plenty of money. And smart managers know that they cannot accept more
without degrading their returns. When too much money chases a limited
number of good investment ideas, investments regress to the mean. Still,
“people are quite flabbergasted, especially very wealthy people, when
you send their money back,” said the FT source.
Last
week, another bit of news reached us: the derivatives market, in which
hedge funds tend to speculate, has reached a face value of $480
trillion...30 times the size of the U.S. economy...and 12 times the size
of the entire world economy. Trading in derivatives has become not
merely a huge boom or even a large bubble - but the mother of a whole
tribe of bubbles...dripping little big bubbles throughout the entire
financial sector.
And
now our friend Simon Nixon reports that the hedge fund industry is
transforming the “social geography of Britain. Fortunes have been
created on a scale and in a timeframe that we have not witnessed for 100
years, if ever before. According to the Daily Telegraph, the average age
of buyers of old rectories - those quaint country houses favored by the
new-moneyed classes - in Britain has fallen by ten years to people in
their early 30s.”
Societies
go through major trends and minor ones; small fads and big ones; cute
little peccadilloes and major public spectacles. Before the Renaissance,
societies were besotted with religion - a passion that burned itself out
in the crusades, the wars of religion, and the inquisition. Then, they
took up politics - and became so wrapped up in ‘isms’ that, by the
20th century, they were killing each other at the fastest pace in
history. More than 100 million people died in the 20th century - victims
of bolshevism, national socialism, communism, nationalism or some other
excess of political enthusiasm.
And
now it is finance that has the world’s attention. China says it is a
‘communist’ country. But it seems not to care. Nor does anyone else
care what the Chinese call themselves. The only thing anyone seems to
care about is that China is open for business. They could throw vestal
virgins into Vesuvius or tear the beating hearts out of their enemies so
long as their economy grew at 10% per year. The Chinese are the envy of
the entire world. Politics has yielded to money.
The
fashion for politics peaked out in the United States during the Kennedy
Administration. Kennedy’s inaugural remarks - ‘ask not what your
country can do for you...ask what you can do for your country’ -
marked the all-time high. That was before the war in Vietnam came a
cropper, and before the war on poverty and the war on drugs were
launched. People believed in those wars and were sorely disappointed
when victories weren’t forthcoming. Now of course, we have a war on
terror...but few people talk about it at all...and no thinking-person
mentions it without an ironic smirk. In fact, the war on terror is
hardly a political war at all - but a campaign designed to protect the
flanks of the great financial empire. If it were discovered that it
diminished consumer spending or raised mortgage rates, for example, it
would be stopped tomorrow.
Now,
it is money that counts. And mommas now want their babies to grow up to
be hedge fund managers. They know where the money is. There’s no money
in religion - unless you’re a TV evangelist...and those slots are hard
to get. Besides, they are more business than religion, anyway. A good
politician, meanwhile, even if he is slick, can only skim off a certain
amount without getting caught with his pants down. The Clintons, for
example, were only able to pull off a shady land deal...and operate a
penny-ante cattle-trading account - besides the book contracts, of
course. It might have been serious money, but it took a whole career of
sordid dissembling to pull it off. The Bushes have done better, but it
has taken them a couple of generations and a few CIA contracts. And in
any case, it is nothing compared to the kind of loot a hedge fund
manager takes in while he is still young enough to enjoy it.
In
this late, degenerate imperial age, no one gets richer faster than hedge
fund managers. Last year, Edward Lampert, of ESL Investments (a hedge
fund business), set the pace with $1.02 billion in compensation.
Compared to him, James Simons of Renaissance Technologies Corp. must
have felt like a charity case, with only a bit more than $600 million in
take-home. But he still did better than Bruce Kovner, at Caxton
Associates, who earned $550 million.
The
New York Times provides a list: Steven Cohen of SAC Capital
Advisors, $450 million; David Tepper of Appaloosa Management, $420
million; George Soros of Soros Fund Management, $305 million (Soros was
number one in 2003, with $750 million); Paul Tudor Jones II of Tudor
Investment Corp., $300 million; Kenneth Griffin of Citadel Investment
Group, $240 million; Raymond Dalio of Bridgewater Associates, $225
million; and Israel Englander of Millennium Partners, $205 million. Poor
Richard Fuld; the man earned only a paltry $35,257,099 for his work
running Lehman Brothers. And E. Stanley O’Neal, at Merrill Lynch got
even less: a miserly $32,134,673.
We
do not report those figures out of jealousy, but simply puzzlement and
amusement. Every penny had to come from somewhere. And every penny had
to come from clients’ money. Investors in leading hedge funds must be
among the richest, smartest people in the world. Still, with no gun to
their heads, they turned over billions of dollars’ worth of earnings
to slick hedge fund promoters.
What
do you need to do to get that kind of work? Well, it helps to be good
with complicated math. Then, you can join other hedge fund managers who
trade derivative contracts that the clients cannot understand, such as
the recently launched CPDO, the Constant Proportion Debt Obligation.
According to Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, the CPDO may be an
innovation, but it is hardly a new idea. It is remarkably similar to the
CPPI, or Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance, which made its debut
20 years earlier.
The
CPDO is meant to protect investors against the risk of investment-grade
credit defaults. CPPI was meant to protect investors from a stock market
crash, using a complex formula that clients also couldn’t quite
understand. Then in 1987, only about a year after the CPPI was
introduced, the stock market crashed and investors finally figured out
how they worked. Sifting through the debris, analysts determined that
CPPI had not protected investors; instead its fancy programmed trading
features actually magnified the losses.
We
don’t know how the CPDO will hold up under pressure, but we can barely
wait to find out. Whenever the higher math and the greater greed come
together, there are bound to be thrills.
The
twitty quants at big investment firms invent the complex derivative
contracts...give them a jolt of juice...and then the abominations spring
to life. The next thing you know, the hedge fund whizzes are building
big houses in Greenwich, Connecticut - and there are billions of
dollars...no trillions...in CPDO and other contracts, in the hands of
buyers who don’t quite understand the elaborate equations behind the
contract...and (here we are just guessing) who will be surprised when
they find out.
If
you are good with figures, you can at least partially protect your own
investments. But it usually means taking a position on the opposite side
of the great weight of investment capital. You can also find ways to
make more money than your slower-moving peers, again, by doing things a
bit differently. But neither financial wizardry...nor any complex
instrument...can protect a whole market. The whole market can’t
protect itself from itself. The more people climb onto an investment
platform - whether it is derivatives, dot.coms, dollars or dirigibles -
the more it creaks and cracks, and the more damage it does when it
finally gives way.
But
buyers of CME (the Chicago Mercantile Exchange) don’t seem to notice.
Google, the newest, hottest technology stock of late 2006, trades at a
forward P/E of 36...CME trades at an astounding 51. CME is where futures
and derivatives trade. The stock came out three years ago at $39. Since
then it’s gone up 14 times, to more than $550. In New York, meanwhile,
the NYSE gets half its daily volume from hedge fund trading. Its stock
too, has been on a roll, now trading at 10 times sales, 119 times
trailing earnings, and 46 times forward earnings.
If
you want to profit from hedge funds, the best way is to become a hedge
fund manager. Or, if you want really want to get into hedge funds, but
wish to retain your dignity, you could consider investing in a hedge
fund company. At least two hedge fund companies have sold shares to the
public on the London market.
But
hedge funds are supposed to be able to produce superior returns for both
investors and managers. If they could do so, why would they wish to
trade their shares for cash? What will they do with the money; invest it
in someone else’s hedge fund? But with returns falling...and customers
beginning to ask questions...more hedge fund impresarios are likely to
want to get out while the getting is good. As the funds become less
profitable, in other words, more will probably be sold to strangers who
don’t know any better.
And
then, someday - perhaps someday soon - a peak in the credit cycle will
come. The mother of all bubbles will finally pop and then the ‘little
big bubbles’ in the financial industry will pop. The Dow will come
down - the dollar too. Junk bonds will sink. Builders in Greenwich will
notice that their phones aren’t ringing as often. NYX and CME will
crash. And 5,000 hedge fund managers will be on the streets...looking
for the next big thing. When will it happen? How? We don’t know. But
our guess is that when the history of this bubble cycle is finally
written, derivatives will get a special ‘tipping point’ place...like
the Hindenburg in the history of the Zeppelin business...or the Little
Big Horn in the life of George Armstrong Custer.

© 2006 Bill Bonner
The
Daily Reckoning Archives
www.dailyreckoning.com
Bill
Bonner is the founder and editor of The Daily Reckoning. He is also the
author, with Addison Wiggin, of The Wall Street Journal best seller
Financial Reckoning Day: Surviving the Soft Depression of the 21st
Century (John Wiley & Sons).
In
Bonner and Wiggin’s follow-up book, Empire of Debt: The Rise of an
Epic Financial Crisis, they wield their sardonic brand of humor to
expose the nation for what it really is - an empire built on delusions.
Daily Reckoning readers can buy their copy of Empire of Debt - now
available in paperback - just click on the link below:
The
Most Feared Book in Washington! http://www.dailyreckoning.com/empireofdebt.html
|