|
In
the popular 1984 film, The
Terminator, current California governor and former actor Arnold
Schwarzenegger plays a cyborg sent back in time to eliminate the mother
of future leader John Connor before he could be born. Single-minded and
highly developed, the robotic killer relentlessly pursues his intended
prey throughout the movie, despite strong resistance fromF the hero’s
supporters, although the good guys eventually win out in the end.
While
the story is pure fantasy, some may not realize that in the stock market
there are the equivalent of dangerous man-made automatons lurking in
every corner. Often technology-based, they are powerful, sophisticated,
and difficult to keep under complete control. Yet they are exerting a
growing and pervasive influence on prices. Unfortunately, these
potential share-price assassins, if they were to be suddenly unleashed
all at once, represent a Terminator-like threat to financial markets,
especially if conditions are just right.
Like
they are now, when the economy is rolling over and share prices have
already begun to correct from historically overvalued and overbought
extremes.
First
among the potentially destructive creations are exchange-traded funds,
or ETFs, which have become a significant feature of the modern
investment landscape. Far too significant, some would say.
Recent
research from Prudential Equity, for instance, suggests that buying and
selling in three small cap ETFs is having a sizeable impact on certain
stocks in the Russell 2000 index. By their reckoning, activity in
Barclays Global Investors’ iShares Russell 2000, iShares Russell 2000
Value, and iShares Russell 2000 Growth index funds accounts for 20% to
40% of turnover in some smaller issues, according to the Wall Street
Journal.
Like
index-related arbitrage and other forms of basket-type trading, such
activity is not driven by fundamentals in the traditional,
Graham-and-Dodd sense, but instead reflects the rapidly expanding role
of various technical, arbitrage, thematic, and macro-type investing
strategies.
The
problem is that while some of this “price insensitive” trading—not
based, in other words, on stock-specific information or insight—has
been a boon for equity markets in recent years amid gushing liquidity
and a mad dash for incremental returns, the negative consequences for
prices as credit, economic, and investment cycles turn for the worse
could be considerable.
Under
the circumstances, index-related selling, for example, could transform
markets in thinly-traded securities that have been unusually liquid and
serene into boggy swamps of illiquidity. This would spur widespread fear
and even a sense of panic, along with a substantial increase in
volatility, as hordes of investors scramble nervously towards the exits.
The
broad use of chart-based, trend-following, and momentum-driven trading
and investing strategies is also likely to exacerbate the market’s
woes in the face of a sustained downturn. With fear a more powerful
motivating force than greed, the herding behavior that such methods
naturally encourage will likely create a snowball effect that will be
hard for anyone—either those diving in or those bailing out—to
resist.
Other
modern risk-management methods and tactics will also fan the bearish
flames once former long-term bull markets start coming apart at the
seams. These include the widespread use of high-powered statistical and
computerized models that measure and help manage risk exposure using
data derived from recent market behavior. When trading conditions are
serene, firms can take on more risk; if prices start swinging wildly,
they must cut back on their exposure, which often means selling into a
falling market.
In
the past, corrections and full-fledged bear markets have been
accompanied by significant price gyrations and converging correlations
between different products, sectors, and markets. When that happens in
an environment like we have now, where there are numerous large
institutions with complex and highly-leveraged bets in myriad markets,
it creates the potential for a seemingly relentless death spiral where
selling leads to increased volatility, begetting further selling.
There
is also the unsettling and potentially destabilizing fallout from the
growing use of portfolio-based margining and risk management strategies.
Aside from the sudden and unwelcome appearance of gaps between expected
and actual risk of loss, rising illiquidity in some markets will force
many participants to try and sell positions or hedge themselves in
others that remain accessible, causing additional markets to quickly
buckle under the pressure.
Another
potential source of destructive energy will likely stem from capital
flows linked to gyrations in foreign exchange markets, a far-reaching
reassessment of trade policies in the face of slowing growth around the
world, and the unwinding of global financial imbalances that are already
at unsustainable extremes.
Moreover,
during uncertain times, history suggests that investors tend to favor
repatriating funds that are invested overseas, regardless of whether the
decision makes sense in the long term.
Finally,
a dramatic increase in outstanding derivatives exposure, especially in
recent years, suggests that violent crosswinds associated with
speculation, hedging, and unwinding will wrack the underlying assets.
Formerly deep out-of-the-money and structural long-term derivatives
positions that were once thought to require little oversight will
suddenly demand active risk management, as will exposure taken on in
more recent times.
Overall,
there are myriad signs that the economic winds are shifting and a
bearish darkness is settling over the investment landscape. It’s worth
remembering, of course, that when the share-price Terminator shows up,
he won’t just be a character in a movie.

© 2007 Michael J. Panzner
Editorial Archive
Michael
Panzner is author of The New Laws of the Stock Market Jungle: An
Insider’s Guide to Successful Investing in a Changing World
and a 25-year veteran of the stock, bond and currency markets. His
next book, Financial Armageddon: Protecting Your Future from Four
Impending Catastrophes is set to be published by Kaplan Business
in February.
Michael
J. Panzner
P.O. Box 115
Manhasset, NY 11030
Website
Email
|