|
Over
140 years ago, German biologist Ernst Haeckel developed the idea of an
evolutionary family tree. Calling
this visual aid for ancestor/descendants relationships phylogeny, he
sought to map out a logical categorization of organisms.
The idea was to make evolution much clearer for the
scientifically uninitiated.
But
it lacked the rigor that science demanded and did not take into account
the simplest of facts: ancestors pass down traits but each new species
is an evolutionary dead end.
Something
happened the other day that might reveal just such a financial
cul-de-sac. Does the
worldwide plunge in stock indexes signal the eve of a new financial
species?
Far
too many investors disregarded economic news
- good or bad. With
an appetite for risk and a thirst for free flowing, cheap cash to fuel
that appetite, they simply plowed forward.
Those days may have come to an end.
For
investors who actively manage their portfolios, the past days have left
them frantically parsing each tidbit of news wondering what new twist
will affect their holdings. Economist and money managers have been
trotted out offering some of the best metaphors, each lovingly adopted
by Wall Street historians for just these types of events. “Don’t try
to catch a falling knife,” one said while another suggested investors
“keep the powder dry”. Both
are references to a “wait and see” approach, the hallmark of a more
conservative, long-term investing philosophy and not necessarily advice.
Yet,
the recent sequence of events seemed to leave even these sage investment
experts baffled. The
requisite reassurances were proffered and expected after such a fierce
and unexpected gyration but they all seemed shallow.
Long-term investors were told ‘that they need not worry’.
It was advice no doubt given by analysts with one eye on the
ticker.
Many
concluded that one possible trigger for the recent worldwide drop in
stocks was the Yen carry trade. This news caught both novice and
experienced investors by surprise.
The
Yen carry trade thrives on low volatility. It is important to keep
in mind that when low volatility thrives, the largest investors have
greater difficulty predicting potential losses, which in turn permits
riskier borrowing strategies. Okay,
but why would this affect the plain vanilla
index fund investor?
The
carry trade works like this: An investor buys currency (borrows money)
from a bank offering low rates. The
money is then exchanged for dollars to buy a bond, preferably one with
high yields and good quality.
The
Yen, which has been available at a 0.5% interest rate, was the prefect
currency to borrow. By
borrowing in Yen, trading that currency for dollars and then using those
dollars (the carry) to buy high yield bonds, investors profited from the
difference. When rumors
surfaced that Japan may be considering yet another rate increase,
investors panicked, flocking in a so-called flight to quality to US
Treasuries. This pushed up prices and yields fell closing the profit gap
further.
Or it
may have started in China. The Shanghai Stock Exchange has been on a
tear of late – up 174% since mid-2005 largely fueled by easy credit.
Individual investors jumped into the markets leveraging their
houses in the hopes of catching the upward surge.
These novice investors panicked when rumors surfaced that the
government was debating a capital gains tax to help slow the fast
growing economy.
This
sent ripples through the commodity markets as well. The phrase Asian Contagion, a throw back to a 1997 event that started when
former then chairman of the Federal Reserve Board Alan Greenspan
suggested “irrational exuberance” has surfaced again
Classic
Greenspan doublespeak was now suggesting that a US recession is
possible. It is a sort of
retraction from a comment he made in Hong Kong predicting that a
year-end downturn was probable. What better way to promote his upcoming
book ”Age of Turbulence”?
Sandwiched
in-between is Mr. Greenspan’s replacement, Ben Bernanke.
The Fed chairman has attempted to remain resolute in the face of
so much unwarranted white noise.
In a
time gone by, the current Fed short-term rate would have performed as
expected. It would have
moderated inflation while keeping employment at a sustainable level.
Although Mr. Bernanke has begun to question this
inflation/employment relationship, the 5.25% level seems about right.
But you have to wonder how long he can ignore some of the economic cries
for help on the home front.
The
US role in the global economy has evolved. Our appetite for goods has
kept equity markets both here and around the world well lubed.
Increasing the cost of borrowed money domestically has succeeded
in slowing our economy. How
slow is slow enough?
The
homes-for-sale inventories in the US have skyrocketed.
There are now roughly four new houses available for every one
buyer. Sub-prime financial
institutions have failed to set aside enough cash to cover their risky
bets and now, the gray market, the one nestled in-between poor credit
quality and excellent is beginning to feel the crunch. GDP has been
revised downward.
After
all the dust settles and it may after a few more exciting percentage
point drops in the next week, will we be witness to a new breed of
investor? Will this new
investor be a shell-hardened predator steeled by several jarring
downturns able to slough off the correction as nothing more than
potholes or something wholly opposite?
We
hope that Mr. Bernanke realizes that we are no longer alone.
Events unfold around us in far-flung corners where we never
expected our investments to venture. While this is neither good nor bad,
it presents us with a new global reality
Dr,
Haeckel would be tempted to add a new branch to this global family tree.
But only if we have successfully changed into a new species of investor;
one that brings a healthier respect for risk and volatility to our
investments; one who is able to navigate this new worldwide landscape
with skepticism and do so with the understanding that this is just the
beginning.

© 2007 Paul Petillo
Editorial Archive
CONTACT
INFORMATION
Paul Petillo
Blue Collar Dollar.com
Portland, OR USA
(501) 313-5252
Email
| Website
|