With
premium gasoline going for $3.50 plus a gallon in many parts of the
country, this may seem an odd time to worry about oil investments. But
with black gold briefly cutting below $70 a barrel this week, it’s as
good a time as any to reassess the prospects of this bull market in
energy, which began in the late 1990s with oil scraping $10.
Like the energy bull
run of the ’70s, this one is fueled by a seismic shift in the balance
of power between producers and consumers. From the mid-’80s to the
late ’90s, consumers held the power in the energy market. Today, it’s
the producers who hold sway, with even the threat of a supply disruption
capable of triggering massive price spikes.
That fact has clearly
been on display during the past couple weeks, as the troubles at BP PLC’S
(NYSE: BP) Prudhoe Bay, Ala., fields sent oil prices to a new high. The
Anglo-American giant had apparently neglected to do necessary
maintenance on its pipelines in recent years and belatedly discovered a
great deal of corrosion that threatened the integrity of its system. It’s
since elected both to make extensive repairs and keep the oil flowing, a
move that calmed the market.
Israel’s invasion
of Lebanon also roiled the oil market in recent weeks, largely because
it sparked fears of a wider conflict with another major producer--Iran.
The danger of such a conflagration is considerably less now that the
Israeli army has begun to withdraw from its forward positions in that
country. However, Israel apparently failed in its objective to take out
the Hezbollah fighters that had been raining death on northern Israel.
And with the Lebanese government not disarming Hezbollah, odds of
another outbreak of hostilities are heavy.
Oil bears point out
that inventories are relatively fat in this country, even as the economy
is apparently slowing down. But as these events show, any surplus under
these conditions--no matter how great it appears--can be sopped up very
quickly. And we have yet to see the worst of this year’s hurricane
season.
Political conflict,
faulty maintenance and harsh weather are, of course, nothing new; they
occurred during the ’90s as well. The difference is there’s far less
of a cushion now. And there won’t be one until we see the same factors
that ended the ’70s bull market in
energy: a real push
for conservation--such as that decade’s move to small cars from gas
guzzlers; a switch to alternatives; at least one major new discovery of
conventional oil and gas reserves on the par with the North Sea of the
’70s; and probably a global recession that kills off demand in the
developing world.
As of now, we’re
seeing none of these factors. Outside of the West Coast, hybrid vehicle
sales are sluggish to stagnant. New nuclear plants are years away
and--despite strong growth at some producers like AES CORP (NYSE: AES)
and FPL Group (NYSE: FPL)--wind power is still only a marginal provider
of energy. Meanwhile, fuels produced from ethanol and Canadian tar sands
are only economic with conventional gasoline at a very high price, and
the cost of producing them is rising, not falling.
The world’s central
bankers could bring on a crushing global recession if they wished. The
US Federal Reserve, however, halted its monthly streak of raising
interest rates, despite signs inflation is far from fully reined in.
That’s a pretty clear sign the Fed and its counterparts are very
concerned about not triggering a recession of the magnitude that will
bring down energy prices in a meaningful way, for fear of far-worse
consequences.
The bottom line is
the long-term foundations of this energy bull market are still very much
intact and are likely to be for some time to come. In fact, a pullback
in oil prices in the near-term will merely further delay the
conservation, alternatives and new discoveries needed to decisively
shift the supply/demand balance back to consumers and end the bull
market.
As long as the energy
bull market runs, high-quality energy stocks will move higher
dramatically over time from current levels. Those who buy and hold are
almost certain to see some dramatic ups and downs in their positions
along the way. But the trend will remain for higher prices, and the best
strategy will be to hold on to good stocks.
The key word here is
quality. There’s no such assurance for those who dabble in the riskier
corners of the energy patch. In fact, it’s quite possible to lose your
shirt, even if oil moves well north of $100 a barrel and gas revisits
the high teens.
The fate of BP
Prudhoe Bay (NYSE: BPT) last week is a pretty good case in point. This
unit trust is basically a royalty stream on the first 90,000 barrels of
oil equivalent per day produced from BPT properties. As oil prices have
risen during the past few years, so has the value of that output. That’s
pushed up the dividend for BPT, and the share price has soared from the
low teens to the low 90s.
All that came apart
quickly as BP’s pipeline problems came to light, with the unit trust
plunging to the low 70s in a matter of hours.
The shares have come
off those lows, and sufficient production has been restored to maintain
the payout. But further pipeline problems, a drop in oil prices or
complications regarding the trust’s scheduled liquidation in 2012
could do it all again, with devastating consequences for shareholders.
Another area for
caution is Canada’s oil sands, particularly the myriad penny stocks
that have sprouted up. Simply, costs of developing oil from tar sands
continue to rise, and even large companies have been put under strain.
The fry have no chance of making it.
Happily, in stark
contrast to the risky side of the energy patch, the quality plays are
still quite cheap, basically discounting another big downleg in energy
prices. That’s especially true of quite a few companies that are
growing production like gangbusters.
Chesapeake Energy
(NYSE: CHK), for example, is on track to boost its output of oil and gas
by 25 percent this year, even as it posted a
308 percent reserve
replacement rate. Yet, because of investor fears about natural gas
prices, the stock trades at less than eight times earnings and just 1.4
times book value.
This is where wealth
is being created in the energy patch--companies like Chesapeake that are
producing at the drillbit. And thus far, the market isn’t giving them
any credit. In fact, many are trading at prices that seem to suggest
natural gas prices as low as $4 per million British Thermal Units (MMBtu)
and oil in the $40 per barrel range.
Super oils are also
very cheap. Leaving aside BP--which is plagued by a host of reliability
problems as well as serious questions about its Russian investments--the
world’s biggest producers and refiners are by and large trading at
single-digit price-to-earnings ratios.
That’s despite
consistent double-digit profit growth. And amazingly, the companies with
rising production are the cheapest of all.
As long as we’re
seeing this level of prices in the context of a very bullish long-term
picture for energy, it’s hard to see how anyone is going to go wrong
buying and holding high-quality energy stocks. That also goes for the
better-quality Canadian oil and gas income trusts like ARC ENERGY (AET.UN,
AETUF) and Penn West Resources Trust (PWT.UN, NYSE: PWE).
In contrast to most
of the smaller trusts--which I would continue to avoid--these are large,
well-capitalized enterprises with solid reserve bases. They can replace
what they produce at a reasonable price and pay out big dividends as
well.
Looking to the near
term, whether or not oil holds $70 a barrel will likely depend on
weather and political events. If there’s a break under $70, look for
energy investments of all stripes to have at least a few bad days, as
they did this week.
Should that happen,
however, it will be a time to pick up more shares of the best-quality
companies--those that are increasing their output and improving their
reserve bases.
There will come a day
when we’ll want to sell even the highest-quality energy plays. But
again, we’re still not seeing anything close to the conservation,
alternatives, new discoveries and probable recession that ended the ’70s
energy bull market. And until we do, high-quality energy stocks will be
essential pieces of everyone’s portfolios.