The Club of Rome...
What straw breaks the camel's back?
by Saif Lalani | March 31, 2008
Print“The Club of Rome raised considerable public attention with its report Limits to Growth, which has sold 30 million copies in more than 30 translations, making it the best selling environmental book in world history. Kevin J. Krizek and Joe Power article: "A Planner's Guide to Sustainable Development" (Planning Advisory Service Report # 467, American Planning Assoc.) mentions this source and his author as stating that Paul Ehrlich's predictions in his 1968 book, "The Population Bomb" will come true within a century. Published in 1972 and presented for the first time at the ISC's annual Management Symposium in St. Gallen, Switzerland, it predicted that economic growth could not continue indefinitely because of the limited availability of natural resources, particularly oil. ' From Wikipedia.org
We are now 1-4 years away from the system breaking down due to limits on natural resources. But which resource will it be?
Drum roll for the contenders......
Oil: Coming in at number 1 for obvious reasons. Nothing else has been mentioned more frequently in the press than this high flying commodity. Conventional world production has peaked. Total liquids production has peaked or will peak within a year or so. Regardless of production the export markets will continue to contract rapidly. Rising consumption in Russia, Saudi Arabia, Iran and Mexico, combined with falling production virtually everywhere of importance will raise prices past $200 within 2 years. High prices are not the problem though. Our system will break-down rather rapidly if oil shortages appear.
Coal: This in my opinion is slightly more likely than oil to bring the system down. Here the effects of export-land model (courtesy Jeffery Brown) are even more pronounced. China consumes more than 2.5 billion short tons of coal per year. It recently turned a net importer (2008 projected). The world export market is tiny and is less than 12% of the world coal production. China's coal consumption is rising at a 12-15% compounded annual rate. China's coal production growth rate is slowing dramatically and will rise less than 5% this year. Putting these numbers together means that China will swallow all of the worlds exports in 2-4 years. Unless coal production can be ramped up dramatically elsewhere it is lights out everywhere.
Natural Gas: This commodity is unlikely to bring the system down as there is still some slack in this market. That said, if coal brings down the first domino then competition for LNG could reach unprecedented levels. That in turn would raise Natural gas prices around the world. Natural gas could also be the first if heaven forbid we have a bad hurricane season in the United States. Back in 2005 there was enough slack in the system. That coupled with an extraordinarily mild winter, prevented natural gas from being the straw that breaks the camel's back.
Uranium: Although uranium prices remain depressed, I remain bullish on it's long term prospects. Within 3 years Uranium prices will at least go past $250 a pound. Once again, it is unlikely to be the first domino to fall but an oil, natural gas or coal crisis could make countries start hoarding uranium. Uranium market is at the mercy of a large amount of non-mine supply. Russia has shown reluctance to part with it and if a worldwide energy crisis is triggered expect the worst from them regarding honoring and extending uranium supply contracts. Of all the commodities, uranium supply has the longest lead time which would make things a lot worse even if below ground resources are present.
Silver: Silver's diverse set of uses make the system particularly vulnerable to it's unavailability. Although silver mine production lags world consumption, a silver crisis is likely to be triggered in a US dollar collapse scenario rather than as a pure supply side situation. Flight into physical precious metal by even 1% of US households would cause marked silver shortages. Say goodbye to all electronics.
Corn, Soybeans, Wheat and Rice: I have previously written about the bullish prospects for corn. The longer term fundamentals for Soybeans, wheat and rice are no less bullish. Rough rice, the least spoken about among the four, has gone up the most in the last 6 months. Our current food stocks are the lowest ever in terms of days supply. When shortages of food appear and hoarding starts does the system survive?
The stage is now set for an epic battle between the Club of Rome and the conventional economists. Will the Club be proven right? Or will the hero of Conventional economists, Adam Smith, come with his 2 sided light saber of supply and demand and defeat the Club?
We will find out soon enough.
Copyright © 2008 Saif Lalani
Editorial Archive
contact information
Saif Lalani | Nashville, TN USA | Email
The opinions of FSU contributors do not necessarily reflect those of Financial Sense.
