|

Perspectives:
The Perfect Financial Storm?
Financial Storms Heading Towards the U.S. Economy

May 26,
2001
© Copyright 2001
James
J. Puplava
IV.
THE ULTIMATE STORM TACTIC - PRECIOUS METALS
The
Gold Market: Suppression or Seismic Anomaly?
Demand
Exceeds Supply
During
the last decade, demand for gold exceeded supply year after year. Under
normal circumstances and in free markets, the price of gold would be expected
to rise. Instead it has steadily declined. Why? Central Bank gold sales and gold
leasing have made up the supply deficit. In the case of central bank sales, the
gold is sold into the open market helping to fill the gap between demand and
supply. Under gold leasing, central banks lease out their gold to bullion banks
who either sell or lend out the gold for sale.

Source:
Veneroso Associates, GATA African Gold Summit, April 2001
By
either estimate in the above tables, the demand for gold has been much greater than mine
supply for the last decade. The logical question is: Why has the price declined? The price of gold has declined because it has been suppressed by
gold sales and leasing and by the paper markets in gold. In fact, there are
many who feel the figures offered by GFMS are clearly understated. Many in the
gold camp believe to account for gold’s price demise, the sale and leasing of gold has been much greater than officially
reported, as shown in Veneroso's sales and loans above figures. Members in the
GATA Camp believe that the numbers reflected in the analysis done by Frank
Veneroso Associates are more accurate.
Holdings
Estimates Difficult to Measure
Because
the precious metals markets are opaque, it is difficult to get
a precise figure on the amount of gold and silver that has been sold
and leased. Suffice
to say the amount has been huge in order to keep the price of gold suppressed
when it is running annual supply deficits. Central banks are the largest
owners of gold in the world. Their gold holdings are estimated to be 33,000
tonnes. GFMS estimates the amount of gold lent out into the market by central
bankers ranges from 3,000-5,000 tonnes. Veneroso & Associates estimates
that figure is considerably higher, more in the range of 10,000-16,000 tonnes.
The amount of physical gold held in central bank vaults is never made public.
So we must deal with estimates based on mine production and demand.

Source: Veneroso Associates, GATA African Gold Summit, April 2001
Lower
Price of Gold Sparks Depressing Chain
Looking at these figures, it becomes obvious that the price of gold is being
artificially suppressed by a constant supply of gold being fed into the
market. This has triggered a chain of events that has further suppressed the
metal's price. The first is that lower prices reduce the supply of gold
by making it unprofitable to mine. Many mines have shut down and new
investments have been held back because mining gold has been unprofitable. Low
returns on investment have kept new capital from entering this market. A
recent Bloomberg article highlighted the fact that gold output worldwide could
plunge by 35% by 2008 due to low prices. 8
Gold production in South
Africa, the largest producer of gold, is estimated to drop by 29% this
year. Similar production declines are expected in Canada, Australia and in the
U.S.
Lower
prices are also driving marginal producers into bankruptcy or out of the
business. These low prices are also preventing the largest producers from opening
new mines. Capital deferrals are increasing and exploration spending has
fallen by 70%. Many mines are running at a loss or are surviving by
going into debt –
eating up their capital or mortgaging future gold
production through hedging.
The
gold mining industry is also going through a period of consolidation. The
average cost of production, including cost of capital, taxes, financing,
exploration and overhead, is pushing the breakeven costs to $290 an ounce.
Because many marginal and smaller producers cannot compete at today’s low
prices, they are going out of business, being forced to merge, or are being
acquired by the larger low-cost producers. Industry consolidation has
caused a vast number of companies to disappear since 1994. In the end, industry
analysts estimate the industry will be dominated by only a handful of key
players. This consolidation phase is not expanding supply –
it is simply
removing it. The survivors are holding back investments and operating only
their low-cost mines.
Lower
prices have also forced many gold producers to sell their gold forward in order
to obtain cash and stay afloat. Forward sales have kept many of the marginal
producers on life support. Bankers are requiring many miners to sell part of
their production forward in order to obtain financing. This practice increases the
paper supply of gold in the market and further suppresses its price. Because the
price of gold has been low for so long, many of today’s miners have been
forced into hedging most of their production. Llarge and small
companies have sold several years of production forward through hedging
programs. This prevents them from ever realizing an adequate return on their
capital. Should gold prices spike as they did in September of 1999 after the
Washington Agreement, when central bankers agreed to limit their gold sales
going forward, those gold hedges could end up bankrupting the companies. This
nearly happened to Ashanti Goldfields.
Gold
Leasing –
Shell Game for The New Millennium
Of
all of the events responsible for keeping the price of gold down,
none is as onerous as the practice of goal leasing itself. Under this scheme,
central banks lease out their gold to bullion banks. The bullion banks either
sell the gold outright or lease it out to others. What is difficult to gauge
is how much of this gold actually leaves the vaults of central banks. In many instances, the
leased gold remains at the central
bank in “custodial” form. The borrower sells the leased gold to another
party in the form of a promissory note. By keeping the gold in its vaults, the
central bank has created the equivalent of fractional gold banking. This
allows the central bank to earn multiple fees on the same amount of gold. This
old shell game works as long as there is never a run on the bank. It works as long as all lessees do not demand physical delivery at the same
time.
Paper
Gold –
Fractional Gold Banking
The
leasing and selling of gold has allowed the paper market for gold to expand at
a more rapid pace. As shown in this chart, the annual production of gold
and silver is much smaller than the paper market. In fact the actually
physical market is dwarfed by paper gold. This world of paper gold has grown and
multiplied in a similar fashion to the credit markets. I call this paper
market for gold "fractional gold banking." It is based on the same
principles as
fractional reserve banking. A small base of actual physical gold has been used
to multiply the market for gold paper.
This
paper gold market consists of options, swaps,
futures, repurchase agreements and loans. The bullion banks treat their metal
deposits in much the same way as they do deposits denominated in money. These
deposits are used as a base for lending. The same amount of gold may be used
in several transactions between sales to producers, jewelers, or other bullion
banks. In this process, the bank may use that one ounce of gold in a half a
dozen transactions. The physical market hasn’t changed, but the paper market
has multiplied. By multiplying their base of lending, banks can collect more
fees in the process. Bullion banks aren’t the only ones playing this
dangerous game. Central banks are guilty of the same practice. Since much of the gold they lend remains in their vaults
in custodial form, central banks are allowed to make multiple loans on the
same amount of gold. This enables them to earn multiple streams of interest on
the same ounce of gold. Like bullion banks, central banks don’t expect that all owners of gold
will want delivery at the same time.
Lessees
and the owners of gold notes are not oblivious to the fact that due to the
size of the gold paper market, there may be more gold leased than actually exist in
central bank vaults. Like depositors at a bank, they are
counting on the fact that not everybody will want physical delivery at the
same time.
| Maturity |
Price |
| Gold
Lease Rates as of 5-21-01 |
| 1M |
2.3500 |
| 2M |
2.3200 |
| 3M |
2.2763 |
| 6M |
2.2559 |
| 12M |
2.4900 |
| Gold
Swap Rates as of 5-21-01 |
| 1M |
1.7000 |
| 2M |
1.7500 |
| 3M |
1.7500 |
| 6M |
1.9000 |
| 12M |
1.9500 |
|
Source:
Bloomberg |
Lethal
Leverage in Gold
It
is estimated by experts in the field that banks have leveraged their lending
business in gold and silver by a factor of 5-10. Some banks are even more
aggressive with factor loadings as high as 40. Hedge funds have been known to
be even more aggressive. LTCM was leveraged by a factor of 100 when it
collapsed in 1998. This shell game works as long as there is no run on the
banks. Since the world of derivatives is mainly settled in cash, it generally
doesn’t present a problem. A large problem, if not a disaster, would occur if
note holders, lenders or lessees were to demand physical gold delivery. Annual
gold production has averaged 2,500 metric tonnes a year. Gold demand has
averaged closer to 4,000 tonnes per year. Annual deficits are now approaching
1,500 tonnes a year. The market has been in deficit for over a decade. That deficit will only get worse as gold production falls due to lower
prices and marginal producers disappear or shut down their mines.
It's
All Just A Paper "Tower of Babel"
So
with gold now running annual deficits of 1,000-1,5000 tonnes a year, with gold
leases now amounting to between 4-6 years worth of outstanding production, what
happens if physical gold is demanded? What could trigger a run on the banks? –
some unforeseen event, a calamity that no one expects, at a time when no
anticipates –
a rogue wave
catching all parties by surprise. If that
were to occur, the paper "Tower of Babel" would collapse by its own weight. It
would be a monetary crisis unlike any we have ever seen. It would be the
financial equivalent of The Perfect Storm. The central banks are aware of this
possibility. It may be the reason that gold lease rates have been rising. It
probably signals the end of the gold carry trade and gold leasing. When
interest rates rise to a level which makes borrowing unprofitable, borrowing
ceases. Without the steady supply of leased gold to dampen prices, the price of
gold should rise to equilibrium levels. Many believe that level to be around
$600 an ounce –
twice the level of today’s market price.
If
investment demand, which has been absent this last decade, comes into play,
then the price of gold would move beyond equilibrium
levels. The rise in the
price of gold would be stratospheric. I'd venture to say that it’s price spike would make the days
of Internet IPOs look tame. Investment demand could be the one factor that
overwhelms the market. Where would the gold come from? Inventory levels have
been steadily declining. The level of current gold production could not meet gold
demand. And it takes years to bring a mine on line. So where would the gold
come from? It won't be found. The only answer would be for
gold to be revalued in price –
rising to its true value.
|
10
Compelling Reasons to Own Gold |
| 1. |
Price
remains at low levels. |
| 2. |
Low
price is discouraging new investment, thereby reducing supply. |
| 3. |
Global
downturn reduces supply of mine output. |
| 4. |
Mines
shutting down because of low prices and energy costs. |
| 5. |
Gold
bullion stocks continue to decline in price. |
| 6. |
Demand
is increasing worldwide. |
| 7. |
Dealers
and intermediaries leaving market, thereby reducing liquidity |
| 8. |
Trading
and volatility levels are dropping off. |
| 9. |
Short
positions are huge. |
| 10. |
Returns
from alternative investments are declining. |
The
Silver Market: Suppression or Seismic Anomaly?
A
similar situation exists in today’s silver market. But, in the case of silver, it
is much worse. As a commodity, silver has been running a supply deficit for
over 11 years. However, in the case of silver, there are no large
central banks to fill the gap. Unlike gold, silver is consumed. In addition to
its financial properties, it has many industrial uses that range from
photography, electronics, batteries, electroplating, medical/dental to water
purification. Industrial demand for silver has grown steadily at an annual
rate of 4.5% a year since 1982. Yet silver production has only grown at an annual rate of 2.4%. Silver, like gold, has been running an annual
deficit for over a decade. Deficits have remained
constant and yet the price of silver has declined.
Supply
and Demand Imbalances
Similar
to gold, silver prices have been depressed by many of the same factors.
Official government sales, leasing, short selling, dishoarding
by investors and producer hedging have all worked in unison to keep the price
of silver depressed. For close to a decade, silver deficits have averaged over
100 million ounces a year. Despite these deficits, its price has declined. As
a commodity, what makes silver unique is that its industrial uses keep
expanding. Its main pillars of demand –
industrial, photography, jewelry and silverware –
keep
expanding into other areas. Demand for silver as an anti-bacterial agent is
expected to double over the next six years. There is also increased demand for
silver as a water purifier. It is used in batteries and now it may also be
used in energy to help increase the output of electricity.
More recently, silver has been used in electronic manufacturing as a
substitute for palladium. Since many of these applications consume silver, the
aboveground stockpiles aren’t as plentiful as gold.
It
is clear from studying silver supply deficits that the market remains
undersupplied relative to fabrication demand. While demand for silver has been
increasing, mine production of silver has been unable to keep up with demand.
Declining prices have forced many mines to shut down while low prices and low
returns have chased capital away from the industry. Many mining companies have been forced into bankruptcy; while other marginal
producers have been kept alive on life support systems through hedging
programs. Lower prices have also caused companies to slash exploration budgets
and development programs. For example, I can think of one silver producer, with excellent mine prospects,
that has held off from development
because of the current pricing environment.
Production
of silver may fall even further in the future should economies around the
globe slow down or head into recession. Free market economies account for 70%
of silver supply. Interestingly, silver is mainly a by-product of
mining other minerals like copper, gold, lead, zinc, nickel and other metals.
Most companies don’t report their production of silver. Instead, they use it
as an offset against their primary metal production. A lot of silver comes
from copper and gold mining. With gold at historically low prices, further
reductions in output are likely. Recently,
companies such as Phelps Dodge, the second largest producer of copper in the
world, have shut down 11% of their production. Many companies have found the
high cost of energy too expensive to run their mines. Companies have found it
more profitable to sell their energy contracts
rather than maintain ongoing operations.
|

|
With
supply deficits remaining, constant mine output has been supplemented by a
draw-down of aboveground stockpiles. The CPM Group estimates that, over the
last decade, silver inventories worldwide have declined by 1.56 billion ounces.
This leaves remaining inventories at their lowest level in two
decades. With no large holders of silver, like the gold
held in the vaults of central banks, silver inventories are more dispersed.
The opaqueness of the metals markets makes it difficult to pinpoint the exact
levels remaining. What is known is simply an educated guess. CPM Group
estimates remaining bullion stocks at between 309 to 534 million ounces. At present rates of consumption, this
would leave between 20-30 months of supply remaining. Individual holdings of
silver coin are around 450 million ounces. However, individuals have been
heavy sellers of silver over the last decade. Last year it is estimated that
they dumped 142.5 million ounces bringing their holdings down to even lower
levels.
|
The
key point of these graphs is that inventory levels have been drawn down.
Aboveground stockpiles are dwindling. Mine production has been unable to meet up
with demand. Investment in new mine production has been minimal. At the same
time, demand for silver continues to grow. This is an untenable situation that
cannot last much longer simply due to the laws of supply and demand. The
fundamental case for silver is compelling if one examines the current
demand/supply imbalance. However, this silver supply imbalance is only one side of
the story.
Investment
Market Imbalance in Silver
There is also a market imbalance. The low price for silver has caused many
dealers and bankers to exit the business. With inventories being drawn down,
many companies in the storage business have no longer found it profitable to
maintain operations. This has removed several key market intermediaries,
thereby making the market less liquid for speculators, traders, commodity fund
managers and hedge funds. When an investment market gets thin, they become
less efficient and less liquid. This discourages new investors from entering
the market. Key players prefer larger, more liquid markets. Lower prices also
threaten long-term price stability. As prices decline, less product is brought to market and made available for investment. It becomes an ever-shrinking market.
Breakdown
in the Price of Silver
The result is that the silver markets have been breaking down. Trading
activity on the COMEX has fallen. Huge short positions have further weakened prices. Last year
silver traded the year down 15% to a price of $4.635. This year,
silver is trading down as well. Volatility, declining option and futures activity, dealers
exiting, and falling turnover levels, make
the silver market less attractive and liquid for investors. Essentially, low
price levels have locked silver into a technical trading pattern making it
difficult to break through. Shorting silver has been a profitable trade much
in the same way as shorting and leasing gold. Currently short positions of 60,297 contracts reportable and 9,113 non-reportable are equal to aboveground
bullion stocks.
| Maturity |
Price |
| Silver
Lease Rates as of 5-21-01 |
| 1M |
1.0900 |
| 2M |
1.1300 |
| 3M |
1.1763 |
| 6M |
1.2359 |
| 12M |
1.6000 |
| Silver
Swap Rates as of 5-21-01 |
| 1M |
3.0000 |
| 2M |
2.9500 |
| 3M |
2.9000 |
| 6M |
2.8500 |
| 12M |
2.7500 |
|
Source:
Bloomberg |
Silver
Leasing Takes A Toll on Investment Return
Silver leasing has further depressed price levels making it easier to
short the market. As this table indicates, lease rates are attractive
remaining under 2%. This allows for more silver to be brought to the market
and sold. But the term "leasing" is a misnomer for the silver and
gold markets –
especially
for silver. The misnomer comes from the aspect of return. When you
lease something, the item isn’t owned. It is borrowed. This implies
that the item leased is eventually returned.
Silver
leasing is like leasing a car for three years. The lessee would have use
of the car for three years. But at the end of the lease term, the lessee has
an obligation to return the car. This example dramatizes the difficulty silver leasing presents to the current lessees of silver. As long as
lease rates remain low, they can roll over their loans and remain profitable.
The problem arises when lease rates rise to a level matching alternative
investment returns and thereby make leasing an unprofitable enterprise. The
leased silver would have to be returned. Which means it would have to be
replaced. Looking at supply deficits and declining inventory levels, this
might present a problem if many lessees and short sellers return to the market
at the same time. Lack of product availability, lack of liquidity, and lack of
alternative venues would cause prices to spike, creating pandemonium in the
silver market.
Because
the metals market is opaque, one never knows what is transpiring in the short
term. Major players accumulate their positions through the international
interbank markets. This affords them greater privacy than buying on the
exchanges like the COMEX. An example would be Buffett’s purchase of silver
through Salomon Brothers. Buffett’s activity only became known after an
investigation into Philbro, one of Salomon’s subsidiaries. Philbro showed
that they weren’t manipulating the market, but were instead acting as agents
for Berkshire’s purchases. News of Buffett’s purchases sent a shockwave
through the silver markets, causing lease rates to spike, silver prices to
jump, and short sellers to rush for the exit gates. This is the sort of thing that
could happen again, but this time it may become more virulent. Why? There is
less supply today then when Buffett accumulated his 130 million ounces.
|
10
Compelling Reasons to Own Silver |
| 1. |
Prices
remain at low levels. |
| 2. |
Low
price are discouraging new investment, thereby reducing supply. |
| 3. |
Global
downturn reduces supply as a byproduct of mining. |
| 4. |
Mines
shutting down because of low prices and energy costs. |
| 5. |
Silver
stocks continue to decline in price. |
| 6. |
Demand
is increasing with alternative uses. |
| 7. |
Dealers
and intermediaries leaving market, thereby reducing liquidity. |
| 8. |
Trading
and volatility levels are dropping off. |
| 9. |
Short
positions are huge. |
| 10. |
Returns
from alternative investments are declining. |
These
ten reasons indicate a very bullish argument for silver. Industrial demand and
alternative uses for silver continue to increase while mining production, new
investment and inventory levels decline. These three issues have been the main
fundamental argument of the silver bulls.
I
believe there is yet another argument that is even more irresistible... What
would happen to the price of silver during a monetary storm or a Perfect
Financial Storm? Very
few mining analysts talk about this subject. Dave
Morgan and James Dines come to mind.
Nowhere
To Run
The
Missing Element: Investor Demand
It
is the position the gold and silver markets would hold, in the event of The
Perfect Financial Storm, that presents such an intriguing study. For as I will shortly
illustrate, there are few places to run to. Metals analysts have made their
bullish arguments on supply and demand fundamentals only. Very few have
entertained the thought of a possible monetary storm. I have shown that both gold and silver
are running supply deficits. Demand has exceeded supply for over a
decade now. The supply deficit has been made up by government and central bank
sales, metals leasing, inventory draw-downs of existing stockpiles, and forward
hedging. Today's inventory levels have been drawn down and remain thin. The one
element missing from a rise in metal prices has been the absence of investor
demand. Two decades of rising stock prices and double-digit returns in the
stock market have lured investors away from precious metals. What could bring
them back?
Higher
prices and higher returns are the only sparks that could revive the precious
metals markets. Without higher prices, you can’t get a high enough return to
attract new capital. From a fundamental perspective, that day is surely
coming. Supply and demand imbalances can’t exist forever. If they did, there
would be no one left in the mining business.
From an economic perspective, a monetary storm such as we had in the 1970’s,
or in fact The Perfect Financial Storm could create a loss in confidence
in the financial system and paper assets. The world of paper currencies
doesn’t have an enduring track record. Gold and silver have existed for as
long as we have recorded history. Fiat currencies on the other hand have a
spotted track record. The inclination to rob people of their assets through
inflating the currency has only worked in the short-run. You can’t keep
people fooled forever.
You can
fool some of the people some of the time. But in the long run, the truth will
always surface.
Confidence
Shift
As long as people have
faith and confidence in paper, the gold and silver markets will have
difficulty competing with paper assets. Paper assets pay interest and
dividends. That cash is spendable. Gold and silver pay nothing unless you own
a dividend-paying mining stock. But in a severe monetary storm, confidence in
paper could quickly evaporate. Until recently, monetary storms around the
globe have favored the dollar. The greenback has been a place of refuge. Investing
in dollars earns investors interest –
something they do not get with gold or silver. The next monetary storm could
expose the weakness in the dollar. Mounting trade deficits, a weakening
economy, and rising inflation rates visa vie the G10 economies make our
financial markets vulnerable. Should the next monetary storm involve the
dollar, where would investors run to with their capital? The answer I believe
will be real money –
which is gold and silver.
In a severe financial crisis involving the dollar, gold and silver could once
again resume their historical role of money.
Should
this scenario play out, the rise in gold and silver would be a
monumental event. The precious metals market is too small to absorb the incremental demand coming from
investors without an explosion in price. I have already illustrated that
demand far exceeds supply. Both gold and silver have been running deficits for
a decade. Those deficits have been made
up by central bank selling and gold leasing in the gold markets. In the silver
markets, aboveground inventories have been vastly depleted. If you add
investment demand on top of industrial and consumer demand, the precious
metals markets would be overwhelmed. There isn’t any excess capacity that
could quickly be brought on line to handle investor demand. And I seriously doubt if under
severe monetary duress, central bankers would part with their only real asset
–
gold.
|
INDUSTRY
CONSOLIDATION |
| 19
Gone |
10
Hanging On
or Going |
13
Survivors or
Take Over Plays |
6
Giants |
| Acacia |
Ashanti
Goldfields |
Agnico-Eagle |
AngloGold |
| Amax
Gold |
Cambior |
Aurora
Gold |
Barrick
Gold |
| Battle
Mountain |
Couer
D'Alene |
Apex
Silver |
Freeport |
| Eagle
Mining |
Echo
Bay Mines |
Goldcorp |
Franco-Nevada |
| Getchell
Gold |
Hecla
Mining |
Harmony
Gold |
Newmont
Mining |
| Great
Central Mines |
Lihir
Gold |
IAMGold |
Placer
Dome |
| Greenstone |
Ranger
Minerals |
Kinross
Gold |
|
| Hemlo
Gold |
Resolute |
Meridian
Gold |
|
| Highland
Gold |
Sunshine
Mining |
Newcrest |
|
| Lac
Minerals |
TVX |
Normandy |
|
| Minorco
Gold |
|
Pan
American Silver |
|
| Pangea
Goldfields |
|
Stillwater
Mining |
|
| Pegasus
Gold |
|
Teck
Gold |
|
| Plutonic
Resources |
|
|
|
| Prime
Resources |
|
|
|
| Royal
Oak |
|
|
|
| Santa
Fe Gold |
|
|
|
| Sutton
Resources |
|
|
|
| Wiluna
Mines |
|
|
|
The
Funnel Effect of Equities Demand
As
the above table indicates, low prices have caused the industry to consolidate.
Weaker companies have gone under or have been absorbed. Nineteen companies no
longer exist. Ten companies are barely hanging on some are on their way out.
Thirteen companies are hanging in there, but could become a target for the
larger players. There are very few equity outlets for investors to run to. The
industry has consolidated so much that there are very few pure gold mutual
funds around anymore. Since there aren’t very many companies to diversify
into, many gold funds have turned into natural resource funds to find a
greater choice of selection. Imagine what would happen to gold equity shares
if even a small portion of the estimated $24 trillion worldwide equity market
turned towards gold and silver.
Physical
Demand Increasing
The physical market would also be incapable of absorbing the inflow of
funds. World gold and silver production is estimated to run around $24 billion
a year. There is no way this market could handle excess demand coming from
investors. Prices would have to head north of the moon to bring aboveground
supplies to the market. Even with higher prices, it would take time to bring
new supplies on line. It is similar to what is now occurring in energy in the United
States. We haven’t run out of oil and gas or the ability to generate
electricity. We have simply run out of excess capacity. The same holds true
for the gold and silver markets. We haven’t run out of gold and silver. We
have run out of spare capacity to deliver it. Like energy, mines have been shut
down in the same way oil and gas wells have been capped. The industry has
consolidated to the point there isn’t the available production that could
quickly ramp up to fill demand gaps. Outside central banks there are no large
supplies available to the market. In the case of silver, there aren’t any
central banks with a large hoard of silver. Besides, in a monetary crisis, even
the central bankers would realize the folly of parting with their most precious
asset.
Over
the last decade the paper markets have given investors the impression that
there are plenty of supplies of gold and silver lying around. The gold and silver derivatives markets have multiplied in
size in comparison to the actual physical markets. Dealers and bullion banks
have been able to pyramid the paper markets on top of the physical market in a
way that is similar to fractional reserve banking. They in effect have
fractionalized the precious metals markets. This explosion of paper has
allowed bankers and dealers the ability to earn multiple fees on the same
ounces of gold and silver. Like fractional reserve banking, there is no problem
unless there is a run on the bank. That is when the shell
game becomes exposed.
...
And No Way Out
If
investor
demand were to return to the precious metals markets, it would create sheer
chaos in the financial markets. We would see bullion banks exposed on their
gold leases. Derivative contracts in
metals would implode. The same would be true for short positions in gold and
silver. Most paper contracts are settled in cash, or in other words, paper.
The metals markets are different. Except for commercials, most contracts are
settled in cash. What would happen if investors in those contracts started to
demand physical delivery instead of cash settlement? You can quickly see the trap the
shorts and the lessees of metals have laid for themselves. There would be no
way out. They would be cornered. Where would the additional silver and gold
come from, if investors wanted physical payment instead of paper or cash?
There is simply not enough stockpiled in the COMEX warehouses. Warren Buffett
owns more silver than what is available at the COMEX. Could this be why he is
holding on to his silver?

Source: Sharefin from http://www.sharelynx.net/
Note: Deficit is the difference between mining production and total demand.
Show
Them No Mercy
This
raises another issue. What happens if some shrewd investors realize the
delicate imbalance that now exists in the gold and silver market? A shrewd
investor could quietly accumulate positions much in the same way that
Berkshire bought its silver. Unlike the days of Bunker Hunt, silver is
incredibly cheap. If you adjust silver for inflation, it is nearly at a
century low. Buffett bought Berkshire’s position with pocket change. There
are many large, sophisticated hedge funds that through the power of leverage
could literally corner the market. If Long Term Capital with $3.5 billion in
equity could borrow $125 billion and control $1.25 trillion in derivatives,
how much easier would it be to do the same in the gold and silver markets? If
annual production of gold and silver amounts to only $24 billion, and if the
market cap of the world's gold and silver equities amounts to only $40
billion, this is not out of the realm of possibility. A company such as GE,
which had $38.4 billion in EBITDA,
could buy all of the world's mining companies with one year of pre-tax income.
They could also buy all of the gold and silver produced in the world.
|
Capitalization
Comparison of Top 5 Companies |
|
Stock
Market Capitalization |
Gold
& Silver Capitalization |
| Company |
Market
Cap |
Mutual
Funds |
Assets |
Company |
Market
Cap |
Mutual
Funds |
Assets |
| GE |
$528
B |
Fidelity
Magellan |
$87.2
B |
Barrick
Gold |
$6.8
B |
Vanguard
Gold |
$275.82
M |
| Microsoft |
$376
B |
Vanguard
500 |
$74.8
B |
Newmont
Mining |
$4.7
B |
Fidelity
Select Gold |
$212.45
M |
| Exxon-Mobile |
$306
B |
Investment
Company of America |
$53.0
B |
Anglogold |
$4.5
B |
Franklin
Gold & Prec. Metal |
$178.00
M |
| Pfizer |
$281
B |
Washington
Mutual |
$46.4
B |
Placer
Dome |
$3.9
B |
Amer.
Century Global Gold |
$135.06
M |
| Citigroup |
$256
B |
Fidelity
Growth & Income |
$36.8
B |
Freeport
McMoran |
$2.3
B |
Scudder
Gold |
$94.06
M |
|
Total |
$1.747
T |
|
$298.2
B |
|
$22.2
B |
|
$.8923
B |
|
Annual
Gold & Silver Production: $24.1 Billion |
What
if?
What would happen, if investors got tired of losses in the equities
markets? What if they realized that inflation was much higher than officially
stated. What could happen to this market, if value investors realized that
silver and gold is selling at or below costs of production? What if some large
investor or fund decided to take advantage of the untenable position of
bullion banks or the gold and silver shorts. What if the shorts and the
lessees asked for mercy and none was given? This is the condition of the
metals markets today. A very thin line exists between price suppression and
price explosion. The difference is ignorance.
The
Gift That Keeps on Giving
For many years now, gold and silver investors have been discouraged by
decades of low prices and more recently by depressed prices. If your only
investment these last two decades has been gold and silver, that is
understandable. However, you are now looking at a gift that will keep on
giving. For the last decade, central banks and their intermediaries, the
bullion banks, have suppressed the price of gold. The central banks have
subsidized the bullion banks through low cost leases. The bullion banks and
the shorts have sold off gold and invested the proceeds in higher paying
investments. In the case of silver leasing and short selling, they have
depressed the price of silver. These machinations have kept the price of gold and silver
suppressed.
There
are two ways of looking at what they have
done which I think will help clarify the present situation. If you are a value
investor, or appreciate a gift when it is given, you will be grateful for the
opportunity. In the act of selling and leasing, gold and silver central banks,
intermediaries, and short sellers have artificially depressed their price. In
effect, they have unwittingly subsidized the price of gold and silver for
long-term investors. If your goal is to buy low and sell high, now is your
chance. Metals prices for gold and silver remain at historical low levels
despite supply and demand imbalances that have subsequently created growing
deficits. Fundamentally, this can’t go on forever. The
lower the price, the less that is produced. Lower prices also discourage new
investments from being made in mining, which prevents supply from ever keeping
up with demand.
If
you are a short-term investor, speculator, or an investor without a sense of
value, this situation may not make sense. There is no "high" in
today's precious metals markets, if you’re a thrill seeker. Buying low
at give-away prices and waiting patiently for them to rise, takes wisdom and
fortitude. If you’re looking to make a fast buck, this isn’t your game. You
may become depressed every time gold or silver prices break or if they remain
confined to a narrow trading range. However, if you are looking at
one of those rare moments in time when the possibility to make a fortune presents itself, this is one of them.
This is a lot like buying equities back in 1981. It was a time when nobody
wanted to buy stocks and bonds. Interest rates were high and equity prices
were depressed. Dividend yields were at 7% and stocks were selling at 7 times
earnings. The consensus thinking was that the equity markets were
dead. Business magazines and experts ran stories about the death of
equities. In much the same way, today's experts talk about the demise of gold and silver markets. When every expert agrees that
the metals markets are dead, it is time to look at resurrection.
Some
Final Thoughts on Precious Metals
The best way to
invest in precious metals is in physical gold and silver. There aren’t large inventories of gold and silver, so you want to make sure
you take possession.
If you are a large investor, look at securing warehouse certificates for your
gold and silver investments. I would suggest reading Ted
Butler’s articles at Gold-Eagle.com and David
Morgan’s writings at Silver-Investor.com. I would also suggest reading
the Gold Derivative
Banking crisis at Gata.org. Subscribing to LeMetropoleCafe.com
is another way to keep yourself informed on the gold and silver markets. I
have listed various websites accompanying this article where you will find
information and different viewpoints to broaden your horizon.
A brief
word of caution when investing in gold and silver equities. You want to be careful when investing in gold
and silver equities. Many companies have hedged all or most of their
production. A major spike in metal prices could actually cause them
irreparable harm. There are only a handful of gold companies worth investing
in. In the case of silver, I can only think of two. It is important that you
understand the risk to mining companies that have hedged all of their
production at today’s low prices. They will not participate to the same
extent as unhedged companies who have major production capabilities and who
sit on prime gold and silver properties. A major price rise could send many of
these hedged companies into bankruptcy. Before you invest in them, obtain an
annual report. Look at the footnotes. Do your homework before you invest. If
you’re not sure about the company's hedge position, call and speak to a company official high up the ladder.
If they won’t divulge the information, avoid investing in that company.
One
final note on investing in the precious metals market. Before investors take any action on
the information and opinions expressed in this article, I recommend that
investors seek the advice of their investment advisor.
Part 10: Riders on The Storm
|
Endnotes
| 1 |
Enochs,
Liz, "U.S. Economy: Spending Spree, Then Slowdown, Bring
Problem Debt", Bloomberg.com,
April 20, 2001 |
| 2 |
"Japan
Unveils Long-Awaited Economic Plan," FoxNews.com,
April 2, 2001. |
| 3 |
Doug
Noland, " The Credit Bubble Bulletin", PrudentBear.com,
May 25, 2001 |
| 4 |
Shilling,
A. Gary, Insight, April 2001 |
| 5 |
Fields-White,
Monee, "U.S. Economy: Borrowers Find Cash in Rising Real Estate
Values," Bloomberg.com,
April 16, 2001. |
| 6 |
OCC
Bank Derivatives Report, Fourth Quarter 2000 |
| 7 |
OCC
Bank Derivatives Report, Fourth Quarter 2000 |
| 8 |
"World
Gold Output May Plunge 35% in 8 Years," Bloomberg, April 11,
2001 |
Reading Recommendations
Internet
Resources
Precious
Metals Sites: Gold-Eagle
Kitco Silver-Investor
Le Metropole
Cafe GATA
Stock Market Sites: Prudent Bear
Fall Street
FiendBear Sharelynx
Elliott Wave
Notes
for Readers:
CAUTION:
This article is for information purposes only. It is general in nature and does
not take into consideration any reader's personal circumstances and/or
investment objectives or needs. Therefore, it has limitations and you should be
aware of this. You should always seek competent, experienced professional advice
before acting on anything you are unsure about. Few forecasts or strategies are
ever one hundred percent correct. Most every consideration, action or strategy
involves a particular or unique type of risk. Seldom is anything really a sure
thing. No specific individual advice is implied or offered to any reader. This
article and others on this web site deal with possibilities and unfortunately,
not certainties.
Perspectives Part 9: STORM TACTICS FOR THE PERFECT
FINANCIAL STORM is the ninth installment of a series on "The Perfect Financial Storm?
Financial Storms Heading Towards the U.S. Economy". You might be interested
in reading the other stories in this series. Please visit the COVER
PAGE.
If you are interested in being notified when the next installment is online,
please complete our FINANCIAL SENSE ALERT PAGE and
note "STORM" in the comments line.
|
|