As the Trump administration pushes to extend the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), the stakes couldn’t be higher—for your paycheck, your business, and the economy. Dan Pilla, a titan in taxpayer rights and IRS abuse prevention, joined Jim Puplava to unravel what’s on the line if this bill stalls. With decades of expertise and a national society of tax pros under his belt, Pilla warns that letting these cuts expire in 2026 could hit hardest where it hurts most: the middle class. Here’s his take on the battle ahead.
Listen to the full audio interview and discussion here: Dan Pilla on 'Tax Cuts for the Rich'? How about the Poor and Middle Class
Middle Class in the Crosshairs
Think the TCJA was a billionaire’s bonanza? Think again. Pilla debunks the “tax cuts for the rich” rallying cry, spotlighting how the law slashed rates most for incomes between $50,000 and $200,000. “The bracket reductions occurred… [in] the heart of the middle class,” he says. “This is where the tax liabilities were cut the most.” If it lapses, the 12% bracket jumps to 15%, 22% to 25%, and 24% to 28%—a gut punch to everyday Americans. Worse, these higher rates kick in at lower income thresholds, a “double whammy” Pilla calls out: “You’re paying a greater percentage of taxes on less income.”
Paychecks and Politics
The fallout won’t wait for 2026 tax season. Pilla predicts an immediate sting: “The IRS is going to… readjust those withholding tables. Jane and Joe American are going to see those tax increases in their paychecks every single week.” Midterm elections loom just as this hits, and he’s blunt about the blame game: “They’re going to blame the sitting administration.” For Trump’s coalition of working-class voters, it’s a risk he can’t ignore.
Small Businesses on the Brink
For entrepreneurs, the TCJA’s Qualified Business Income (QBI) Deduction is a lifeline. Pilla breaks it down: a business netting $100,000 shaves 20% off taxable income—down to $80,000—without spending a dime. “They don’t have to spend the money to get the deduction… the money’s still in your pocket,” he emphasizes. It phases out above $415,000-$425,000, targeting middle-class owners, not moguls. Let it expire, and small businesses—already battered by inflation—face a brutal hit.
SALT: The High-Tax State Showdown
The $10,000 cap on state and local tax (SALT) deductions sparked howls from high-tax states like California and New York. Pilla finds the irony rich: “They were crying that the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was ‘tax cuts for the rich,’ but… limiting that deduction… increased the taxes for high-income people.” Now, GOP reps in these states are pushing Trump to lift it, threatening to tank the TCJA if he doesn’t. Pilla sees a compromise brewing—maybe a $100,000-$150,000 cap or full repeal—to win them over.
AMT’s Middle-Class Creep
The Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT), once a net for the ultra-wealthy, morphed into a middle-class trap as inflation eroded its brackets. “A greater and greater share of the population found themselves subject to the AMT,” Pilla explains. The TCJA reined it in, but if it fades, “the average Jane and Joe American taxpayer is getting clobbered” again by this flat-tax beast—stripping deductions and jacking up bills.
Real Estate’s Silent Tax Bomb
Homeowners, beware: the 1997 capital gains exclusion—$500,000 for couples, $250,000 for singles—hasn’t budged since Clinton’s era. “With the inflation that has hit… it’s not that unusual for somebody to have $600,000 or $700,000 equity,” Pilla notes. Sell now, and you’re taxed on the excess—often pure inflationary gain, not profit. “It ends up being a negative gain,” he says, slamming the lack of indexing as a stealth tax hike.
Trump’s Bonus Bets: Tips, Overtime, and Social Security
Trump pitched tax-free tips, overtime, and Social Security. Pilla’s optimistic on the latter: “There’s no good reason for Social Security benefits to be taxed… That income was taxed once already.” From zero tax pre-Reagan to 85% under Clinton, it’s a sore spot for retirees. “It’s such an emotional thing for people to have paid taxes all these years… and now they want to tax it again,” he says. Tips and overtime? “Very little chance”—too tricky to enforce.
Will It Pass? Pilla’s Odds
Handicapping Congress is dicey, but Pilla’s bullish: “I personally believe that there is a 100% chance that the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act will be renewed in its substance.” Social Security tax relief and a SALT overhaul are likely riders; tips and overtime, less so. With GOP pressure and electoral math at play, he sees Trump threading the needle—averting a 2026 economic crater.
Your Tax Lifeline
Facing IRS woes or tax traps? Pilla’s your guy. At taxhelponline.com, grab a book (like Dan Pilla's Small Business Tax Guide) and snag a free 15-minute consult with him. “Write your questions down, and I will walk you right through,” he offers. As the TCJA’s fate hangs, Pilla’s clarity is a middle-class must-have.
For related podcast, see Dan Pilla on 'Tax Cuts for the Rich'? How about the Poor and Middle Class. If you’re not already a subscriber to our weekday FS Insider podcast, click here to subscribe.
For a link to our full podcast archive, see Financial Sense Newshour (All) and don't forget to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube Podcasts!
To learn more about Financial Sense® Wealth Management, give us a call at (888) 486-3939 or click here to contact us.
Advisory services offered through Financial Sense® Advisors, Inc., a registered investment adviser. Securities offered through Financial Sense® Securities, Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC. DBA Financial Sense® Wealth Management. Content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or other advice
