In 2008, and again now in 2011, Congress has been looking for a Bogeymen to blame for a rise in oil prices. Since the rise in oil prices almost certainly has to do with factors outside their control – such as rising demand in developing markets and constraints in cheap supplies – they must frantically search for something in their control such as people to blame. Such is the life of a politician. One of the Bogeymen they have zeroed in on is the commodity speculator, a term not well defined but probably meaning any bank, mutual fund, hedge fund, or financial firm that buys or sells commodity futures, derivatives, and swaps, and perhaps also includes people who buy ETFs such as USO (oil), UNG (natural gas), or DJP (commodities). They cast a wide net, but it is into a barren sea, for the case against commodity speculators is deeply flawed. My hope is that this article presents an alternative view into the role of commodity speculators and helps end the misplaced focus thereon for rising oil prices. As this is only one of several important financial issues where honesty will set us free, we need leaders who are willing to level with the American public about economic truths in the place of demagoguery and witch-hunting.